How does direct mail marketing compare to email marketing?

How does direct mail marketing compare to email marketing?

Both email and direct mail have their strengths and weaknesses. Email is fast, cheap, and easy to scale, but is often overlooked in busy inboxes. Direct mail takes longer to produce but cuts through the noise and drives high-intent engagement. The most effective marketing programs use both, each playing a distinct role.

‍

Let’s take a closer look at how they compare and when to use each.

‍

How do email and direct mail compare for reach and visibility?

Email is great for nurturing known contacts – it’s quick, cost-effective, and easy to automate. But it only works if you already have someone’s email address and their permission to use it. Regulations like CAN-SPAM and GDPR keep email targeted, but also limit its reach.

‍

Direct mail gives you more flexibility. You can retarget website visitors using pixel data or target new audiences. With tools like Lob Audience, marketers can target high-intent prospects based on behavior, location, or demographics, not just existing CRM records.

‍

In terms of visibility, physical mail stands out in a crowded digital world. According to the State of Direct Mail 2025: Consumer Insights Edition, 56% of consumers say they remember brands better from mail than from digital touchpoints, making it a powerful way to leave a lasting impression when done well.

‍

Use email to reach known contacts with frequent, personalized messaging.

Use direct mail to broaden your reach and drive high-impact engagement with new or re-targeted audiences.

How do email and direct mail compare in terms of cost and efficiency?

Email is cheap – there’s no getting around it. Once you’ve built your list, you can send thousands of emails while sticking to a lean budget. But that low price means that everyone else is using email marketing too. And they’re using a lot of it.

‍

Direct mail costs more to produce and send, but it often delivers stronger results per impression. And when targeted to the right audience, it drives serious ROI. In fact, 79% of executives rank direct mail as the top-performing marketing channel. When combined with digital channels, it can actually improve overall campaign performance. According to the State of Direct Mail 2025: Consumer Insights Edition, 41% of consumers say they’re more likely to engage when they receive both digital and physical touchpoints from a brand. Modern platforms also make it easier than ever to automate and scale mail, so you’re not trading efficiency for impact.

‍

Use email when speed and cost are top priorities, like flash sales, updates, or ongoing nurture.

Use direct mail when you want attention, recall, and conversion – and to reinforce digital campaigns for stronger results.

‍

How do email and direct mail compare for personalization and relevance?

Email has long been the go-to for personalized marketing, from subject lines to dynamic product recommendations. But direct mail has caught up. Today’s platforms let you personalize creative, timing, and even formats at scale, based on customer data from your CRM or CDP.

‍

And relevance matters. According to the State of Direct Mail 2025 report, 72% of consumers throw out mail that doesn’t apply to them, while 67% say they’re more likely to take action when the message feels personalized. The same principles that drive strong email performance – segmentation, behavioral triggers, and clear calls to action – apply to mail, too.

‍

Use email to test and deliver frequent personalization that adapts quickly.

Use direct mail to deliver meaningful, well-timed messages that feel tailored and worth the attention.

‍

The bottom line

Email and direct mail aren’t in competition – they’re complementary. When used together in an omnichannel strategy, they reinforce each other and drive stronger results than either channel on its own. For more info, check out our guide to omnichannel marketing here.

‍